Divorce can be thought of negatively and accurately as a self-inflicted wound that harms people other than the once-married couple.
Divorce Detox is a therapeutic counseling regimen for folks going through divorce; divorce "recovery" may be more apt. The Santa Monica, CA based program will not cure you, but you will feel better about yourself. And in the Hell that is the divorce process, that has high value.
This peace-of-mind does not, of course, come cheaply. The standard fee is $2500 and basically includes their "group therapy" package; an extra thousand gets you a series of individual counseling sessions. That's about what folks out here in the Midwest pay as an initial retainer for their divorce attorney.
Divorce Detox features hours of classes, therapy and homework. A 100+ page workbook accompanies the materials. One of the tools that caught our eye is the letter each seminar attendee is required to write to oneself at the beginning of the seminar. Collected upon "intake", this letter is mailed back to the participant several months after completion of the course.
The core principle of Divorce Detox is to turn a [very] negative experience into a positive. The program focuses on mind, body and soul.
The process involves one common to most forms of therapy generally: identifying one's problems through careful and deliberate introspection; and addressing those problems, owning them, prior to moving on as a divorcee.
The program even has a blog, although we here at the electronic divorce attorney note that quite a bit of time goes by between posts...
www.clarkstonlegal.com
info@clarkstonlegal.com
Thursday, December 20, 2012
Sunday, December 16, 2012
Six Holiday Parenting Tips
Often, tensions escalate over the holidays as divorced parents struggle with the demands of scheduling the children to accommodate two households. Holiday schedules are already difficult without the complications of a divorce judgment or divorce proceeding.
Here are some practical tips in dealing with holiday parenting time gleaned from divorce lawyers around the state.
- Reduce an alternating holiday schedule to a court order. It is always best for the children when the parents can agree on a schedule. Alternating holidays is most common when drafting the parenting schedule. When both parents live close to one another, many families utilize a shared holiday model where the children spend time with one parent until noon, and the other parent for the balance of the day; then the next year, they switch. This works for Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Year's Day and other holidays.
- Discuss the schedule with the children. One solid co-parenting tactic is for both parents, once an agreement is reached, to communicate the schedule to the children. This way, the children know in advance what to expect. This can best be accomplished when both parents commit to rational communication and reasonable compromise for the children's sake.
- Keep the activities simple. This tip is particularly essential when the children are relatively young and if the divorce is still fresh. The wounds of the once-whole family have yet to heal; holidays are particularly painful for both children and parents. Therefore, it makes sense to tone down the activities and avoid rushing hither and yon during your now-scheduled parenting time.
- Let your child express her feelings to you. It is important to allow your children the opportunity to express their feelings of loss and disappointment and for you, as the parent, to validate those feelings. What the child once experienced as an intact family unit has been fractured by divorce. Therefore, pretending that everything is fine, or over-scheduling a whirlwind of activities to the point of distraction, will only add to the stress of your holiday parenting time.
- Involve your extended family. The more love the child feels during the years immediately following a divorce, the better. Therefore, schedule some quality family time with members of your extended family. Certainly, this would be a great opportunity for your children to spend time with their grandparents, aunts, uncles and cousins. If your extended family is highly dysfunctional then, er, not-so-much.
- Avoid including a new "significant other". This is the last thing you want to do at the holidays; not the time or the place. Including your "significant other" too soon is a selfish thing to do to your children. Upon reflection, you would probably agree that you would be doing that for yourself, certainly not for your children. Children of divorce already struggle with guilt, a sense of loss, and insecurity. They often perceive the introduction of a stranger, especially one that is close and intimate with their parent, as a threat, not a benefit from their parents' divorce.
Finally, a positive parental attitude over the holidays does wonders for a child's comfort and confidence. Be the adult, not the child.
Post Note: For another local attorney's take on this subject, take a look at our friend, Henry Gornbein's post in the Huffington Post Divorce Blog.
Post Note: For another local attorney's take on this subject, take a look at our friend, Henry Gornbein's post in the Huffington Post Divorce Blog.
Thursday, December 13, 2012
False Claims in Custody Battle Will Bite You Back
Written by Family Law Lawyer Amanda Chapman
Let’s face it – it’s no surprise that emotions run high
during a divorce where custody of the children is at issue. With divorce comes uncertainty, and
uncertainty regarding where your children will live, and with whom, is a
nightmare for most parents.
Sometimes, when in the midst of doing battle for those that we
hold most dear, we think in terms of winning “at any cost.” But be wary if you
find yourself contemplating such thoughts – you may do yourself more harm than
good.
To illustrate the point, a recent unpublished
Michigan Court of Appeals opinion, Henry. Henry (decided December 22, 2011) involved a divorcing couple, Christine
and Doug, and their six children. The
parents were both battling for custody of the children, which resulted in a
trial held in Wayne Circuit Court. The trial court was required to contemplate
the statutory “best interests” factors, which include making a determination as
to the “moral fitness of the parties involved.”
In weighing the “moral fitness” best interest factor, a
trial court must determine a party’s fitness as a parent, looking to the
parent-child relationship and how that parent’s conduct affects that
relationship. In the Henry divorce, the trial court heard testimony from various
individuals who suggested that Christine had filed false reports [involving
issues of possible child abuse or neglect] with several professionals and
agencies. Ultimately, the trial court did not find Christine’s testimony
credible, as the court weighed more heavily in favor of witness testimony which
supported Doug’s claims that the reports were “inaccurate, manipulative, and
designed to force additional investigations.
The court, in evaluating the “moral fitness” best interest
factor, must determine the effect of a parent’s conduct on the relationship
with their child. In this instance, the trial court deemed this factor to weigh
in favor of Doug, determining that Christine’s false reports to various
agencies “could have a negative effect on the children.” The Court of Appeals, in reviewing the trial
court’s decision, deferred to the trial court, as this was ultimately an issue
of credibility.
The moral of this story: don’t make false claims against the
other parent in an effort to make them look bad in your custody case. Not only
does it waste precious resources for those who need protection, but it might
ruin your credibility in the eyes of the Court.
Friday, November 30, 2012
Sibling Visitation - Does it Exist?
We have all heard the term “visitation” before,
especially if you have been involved in a child custody dispute or divorce. The term most often used by family law lawyers and professionals is “parenting time”; referring to the
legal right [and obligation] of a parent to spend time with one’s child following a divorce.
Even grandparents, under
limited and specific circumstances, may have a legal right to visit with their
grandchildren according to Michigan law.
But what about siblings? Does a
brother or sister have the right to visit their sibling, if for some reason
they are no longer living within the same household?
The short answer is that sibling visitation is not recognized as a legal right in Michigan. The Child Custody Act does not provide for visitation rights between siblings. Add adoption into the mix and the result remains the same – but for a more
specific reason.
Earlier this month, the Michigan
Court of Appeals grappled with, and attempted to decide
this very issue in Wilson v King; a published thus binding opinion of the intermediate appellate court.
Marquita Wilson, the plaintiff-mother in this case, had
three children who were eventually adopted into a new family in 2008 after her
parental rights had been terminated. Ms.
Wilson then gave birth to a fourth child; Mac.
The adoptive parents of Ms. Wilson's three children initially
allowed Mac to visit with his siblings. Sadly, for reasons not stated in the Court
of Appeals opinion, the adoptive parents ultimately discontinued these sibling visits.
Ms. Wilson filed
suit on behalf of Mac in Wayne County Family Court. The family court judge dismissed the claim on the
basis that the right to “sibling visitation” does not exist under Michigan Law. On appeal, Ms. Wilson argued that Michigan law does provide for a cause of action for
sibling visitation and that the lower court had erred in dismissing her
case.
The Court of Appeals upheld the
trial court’s decision – but did not find one way or the other on whether or
not Michigan law provides for a cause of action for sibling visitation. Instead, the Court focused on the fact that
Mac’s older siblings had been adopted.
Adoption legally severs any ties to the prior, natural family, and creates,
in its place, a new adoptive family recognized at law. This means that, legally speaking, Mac’s older
siblings (once they had been adopted) were no longer his legal siblings in the eyes
of the law.
The Court of Appeals held that even if
a cause of action regarding sibling visitation existed (which the Court made
sure to footnote that they offered “no opinion as to the viability of such a
claim”) in Mac’s instance the claim must fail as the three adoptive children
were no longer his siblings.
While we recognize the psychological importance of eliminating contact with biological parents in order to facilitate growth in the new adoptive family, this ruling strikes us as similar in spirit to the old paternity act that denied a biological father standing to seek any parenting time with his child whatsoever.
The ruling seems to foster the notion of wiping-out all traces of the adopted child's biological family. Many adopted children, as they mature, seek out traces of their biological families. Some of these children, as they mature into adulthood, obsess over their lost families and seek therapy to deal with the loss.
At base, however, there is really no-way in cases like this to allow sibling visitation, without also focusing on the biological parents. Our adoption laws currently do not provide for the maintenance of two families; just one: the adoptive family.
Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Women Often Lose Health Insurance in Divorce
Long-term marriage has been an endangered species for some time in our society. Couples in the United States divorce at the rate of approximately one million times each year.
Divorce is Hell for both men and women. Even in our post-modern society, however, women still seem to get the brunt of the pain.
According to a recent study published by the University of Michigan, approximately 115,000 women nationwide lose their health insurance coverage as a direct result of the divorce process. Of these, some 65,000 never re-gain coverage.
The study was conducted by Bridget Lavelle, a UM sociology doctoral candidate. Ms. Lavelle examined literature and data from survey respondents who divorced between the years 1996 and 2007. The December issue of the Journal of Health and Social Behavior will feature the study.
Lavelle postulates that women's loss of health insurance benefits is not just a temporary disruption resulting from the divorce process. Rather, she concludes that the loss of health insurance coverage for women is a long-term problem that compounds the economic losses of divorced women.
What's worse is that mid-income women have the greatest risk of loss of coverage because they do not qualify for Medicaid or other safety-net coverage options available to lower income divorcees.
We here at the Law Blogger wonder what effect Obamacare and the Affordable Care Act will have on this equation next year when everyone must carry insurance by mandate of federal law.
When facing a divorce, if you are at risk of losing your health insurance coverage, consider demanding some form of short-term alimony payments sufficient to cover the 3-year period of COBRA available from your spouse's employer. Or, in the alternative, shop for comparable affordable health insurance.
The short-term alimony approach will at least cover women during the initial transition from marriage when, as posited by Ms. Lavelle, they are most at risk to lose health insurance coverage, and suffer even greater economic hardships as a result.
www.clarkstonlegal.com
info@clarkstonlegal.com
Divorce is Hell for both men and women. Even in our post-modern society, however, women still seem to get the brunt of the pain.
According to a recent study published by the University of Michigan, approximately 115,000 women nationwide lose their health insurance coverage as a direct result of the divorce process. Of these, some 65,000 never re-gain coverage.
The study was conducted by Bridget Lavelle, a UM sociology doctoral candidate. Ms. Lavelle examined literature and data from survey respondents who divorced between the years 1996 and 2007. The December issue of the Journal of Health and Social Behavior will feature the study.
Lavelle postulates that women's loss of health insurance benefits is not just a temporary disruption resulting from the divorce process. Rather, she concludes that the loss of health insurance coverage for women is a long-term problem that compounds the economic losses of divorced women.
What's worse is that mid-income women have the greatest risk of loss of coverage because they do not qualify for Medicaid or other safety-net coverage options available to lower income divorcees.
We here at the Law Blogger wonder what effect Obamacare and the Affordable Care Act will have on this equation next year when everyone must carry insurance by mandate of federal law.
When facing a divorce, if you are at risk of losing your health insurance coverage, consider demanding some form of short-term alimony payments sufficient to cover the 3-year period of COBRA available from your spouse's employer. Or, in the alternative, shop for comparable affordable health insurance.
The short-term alimony approach will at least cover women during the initial transition from marriage when, as posited by Ms. Lavelle, they are most at risk to lose health insurance coverage, and suffer even greater economic hardships as a result.
www.clarkstonlegal.com
info@clarkstonlegal.com
Saturday, October 20, 2012
The Grey Divorcee
A recent study published by the Bowling Green State University concludes that divorce has replaced widowhood as the primary reason many seniors are single later in life. No surprise there, as the United States has long held the highest divorce rate in the world.
As the baby-boomer generation ages, more of its members have been divorced than in any prior generation at any point in history. Add to this the more complex marital biographies of average baby-boomers [second marriage, recently divorced, ever divorced], and you cannot ignore the growing prevalence of divorce in our society.
The study concludes that as widowhood has declined over the past two decades, the divorce rate among the middle-aged and seniors has doubled. Also of note in this demographic is that, among divorced seniors, they achieved this status much earlier in their lives than in the past.
Another conclusion drawn by this study is that over the next two decades, as the growth of the "older" population accelerates, so will the divorce rate among mature adults.
One option to consider is separate maintenance. This option, although not for everyone, has the advantage of allowing an unemployed spouse to maintain health insurance coverage. In most cases, this saves the unemployed spouse approximately $500 per month by not having to pay an insurance premium.
If you are over 50 and facing the tough options of divorce in Oakland County, contact us for a free consult. We can provide you with answers to your questions and concerns.
www.waterfordlegal.com
info@waterfordlegal.com
As the baby-boomer generation ages, more of its members have been divorced than in any prior generation at any point in history. Add to this the more complex marital biographies of average baby-boomers [second marriage, recently divorced, ever divorced], and you cannot ignore the growing prevalence of divorce in our society.
The study concludes that as widowhood has declined over the past two decades, the divorce rate among the middle-aged and seniors has doubled. Also of note in this demographic is that, among divorced seniors, they achieved this status much earlier in their lives than in the past.
Another conclusion drawn by this study is that over the next two decades, as the growth of the "older" population accelerates, so will the divorce rate among mature adults.
One option to consider is separate maintenance. This option, although not for everyone, has the advantage of allowing an unemployed spouse to maintain health insurance coverage. In most cases, this saves the unemployed spouse approximately $500 per month by not having to pay an insurance premium.
If you are over 50 and facing the tough options of divorce in Oakland County, contact us for a free consult. We can provide you with answers to your questions and concerns.
www.waterfordlegal.com
info@waterfordlegal.com
Thursday, October 11, 2012
Double-Dipping for Alimony
![]() |
| The original "double-dip". |
Meanwhile, a fellow party-goer and disgusted onlooker cannot contain the impulse to put a stop to this obvious dip-contaminating behavior and confronts George. Inane hilarity ensues; check it out here. [Note: Post-Seinfeld generation and long-time Seinfeld enthusiasts – you’re welcome.]
Double-dipping, in the world of family law, typically refers to the way assets are valued in the division of a marital estate. A recent Michigan Court of Appeals decision, Loutts v Loutts, addresses this issue of “double-dipping” in the spousal support context.
This divorce case originated in the Washtenaw County family court. One of the main issues in the case was how to determine an appropriate spousal support award where the marital assets included a business valued at more than a quarter million dollars.
The husband started, owned, and operated the business. When the family court awarded half of the business value to his wife, the question became: what income should be imputed to husband now that half the value of the business had been conveyed to wife?
When determining spousal support, the parties’ incomes must be determined so that the family court may decide how to equitably balance the incomes. The Michigan Court of Appeals has articulated a balancing test such that:
the primary purpose of spousal support is to balance the parties’ incomes and needs such that neither party will be impoverished, and spousal support must be based on what is just and reasonable considering the circumstances.The family court can only perform this balance test on a case-by-case basis – typically unwilling to follow any bright-line rules for determining the rate and term of a spousal support award.
The family court in Loutts, after awarding wife half the value of the business, imputed approximately $130,000 income to husband. This imputed income was utilized to “equitably balance” the incomes of the parties.
In doing so, the family court judge relied on case law to determine that “the value of a business may be used for the purpose of either property distribution or spousal support, but not both.” On appeal, wife argued that the court should have used the full-value of the business in determining her spousal support award.
The Court of Appeals disagreed, remanding this issue back to the family court for a re-determination of spousal support based upon the specific facts and circumstances of the case. In their opinion, the Court of Appeals stated that the trial court’s reliance upon the Heller v Heller case was misplaced to the extent that, “the appellate court stated that its determination that a double-dip was inequitable was based on the facts of that case alone and was not a determination that double-dipping is never permissible.” [The emphasis is ours.]
The obvious "take-away" from this recent case is that, when it comes to determining spousal support, bright-line rules simply do not apply. Rather, the family court judge should consider a variety of factors, including: the conduct of the parties, their ability to work, their ages, needs, health, present situation, prior standard of living, ability to pay alimony, and general principles of equity.
Double-dipping might be ok – given specific factual and equitable circumstances. Exactly what those circumstances are remains a fuzzy, mutable, arguable enigma, ripe for the art of legal persuasion.
The one constant is that each case before the family court is unique and should be considered so by the judge.
Also of note in the Loutts decision is that the Court of Appeals wasted no time in upholding a 3-year non-compete provision that applied to the business and to which wife agreed, but appealed. The Court held that you get what you bargain for.
www.waterfordlegal.com
info@waterfordlegal.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)













